Pizzetta
Their slogan is perfect because there is no exaggeration. Everything is homemade including: the pasta, sauce, and even the sausage. The combination of food and price were so good that we had to drive to Old Koloa Town on the south side of the island twice.
We had a pepperoni and pineapple pizza. The dough was obviously homemade and cooked to perfection. The sauce was sensational! We are still searching for a pizza in California that could even come close to what we tasted there. On another trip, Frank ordered the spaghetti. Again, the pasta was homemade and perfectly cooked. The sauce had chunks of fresh grown tomatoes in it. Only in Italy could he get anything better than what he tasted that evening. We both had a huge, rich, chocolate brownie topped with vanilla ice cream and hot fudge. Not even Claim Jumper restaurants could compete with this.
Again, the price was low but the food was GRRREAT!